The school: a place to find them, and a blind spot
Precisely because young people spend so much time at school, education is an important place to pick up on warning signs. At the same time, it is a place where those signs are easily missed.
Three out of four secondary schools in the Netherlands have, in the past five years, dealt with a pupil involved in a serious form of crime. This is according to research among almost 700 education professionals by researcher Jennifer van den Broek. The offences included drug dealing, storing weapons, doing odd jobs for criminals and acting as a money mule.
The role of schools can also go further than that of a place to find potential perpetrators. The SKC report shows that criminals sometimes fund courses or steer young people, via family ties, towards specific vocational programmes, such as electrical engineering or healthcare. These young people can later be deployed strategically, for example in cannabis grow operations or in managing money flows.
Yet knowledge of organised crime within education is limited. Only 6 per cent of school staff receive training on the subject. Half do not know what signs to look for, and only 14 per cent are familiar with specific protocols, for example on drug-related crime.
This makes early detection complicated. Most signs are, after all, ambiguous. Tiredness, falling grades or regular lateness can have countless causes. Only when several signs come together may a different pattern become visible.
Professionals describe, for example, young people who are constantly ‘switched on’ at school. They seem permanently alert to what is going on around them. This may mean that outside school hours they are in an environment where they constantly feel threatened or watched. They come home late, sleep little, fall behind at school and eventually sometimes call in sick.
Other signs are more conspicuous: young people who suddenly have expensive clothes or several phones, who are regularly picked up by strangers in expensive cars, who appear in video clips with people from the criminal underworld, or who put the name of a youth gang in their Instagram bio.
But here, too, there is an important pitfall. Not every young person involved in crime stands out. Those who function well and get good grades can sometimes keep their school life and their activities outside remarkably separate. This is precisely why they stay out of sight for longer.
Silence born of fear
There is something else: young people often don’t say what is really going on. Fear of the consequences and of possible reprisals keeps them quiet. At home, at school and even in front of a judge, they may stay silent about the people influencing them.
This makes it difficult to get young people out of a criminal network. Even when they stand before a judge, they don’t open up. The judge: ‘You don’t want to write them off, you want to get them out of that criminal group. They get caught because, for example, they threw Cobra fireworks and were arrested for it. Or because their DNA was found, because onlookers recognised them, or because they shared videos of the incident with others. But when they’re standing in front of you, they say they’re afraid to make a statement. That makes it hard to arrive at effective measures that, alongside the punishment, are aimed at strengthening these young people so that they escape the influence of the middle management of a criminal organisation.’
The school as a line of defence
Schools, then, hold an important position. But a great deal is asked of them. Teachers must teach, act as mentors, identify warning signs and refer pupils on where necessary. At the same time, schools are struggling with staff shortages and high workloads. The SKC report makes clear that this combination limits the capacity to act on warning signs.
Some schools are also wary of reputational damage. A school known as a ‘problem school’ can lose pupils. This can lead to signs of criminal risk being kept internal or not being followed up adequately.
Yet the school’s role is not only about spotting signs and referring pupils on. The culture in the classroom matters too. Which ways of interacting are considered normal? How safe do pupils feel? Can sensitive subjects be discussed? And what happens when peer pressure, tough behaviour or silence becomes the norm?
Teachers have influence over this. Not only by setting rules, but above all through the example they set and by creating a safe space in which pupils dare to tell them things.
This matters particularly where criminal interference is concerned. A young person may come into contact with crime through social media, friends or family, but may also be drawn in by the prospect of quick money. In a classroom where this can’t be talked about, that development easily remains invisible.