Many entrepreneurs think of criminal interference primarily in terms of fraud, reputational damage and financial loss. But criminal interference often affects something more fundamental: the culture of the organisation. Anyone who fails to understand how criminal networks operate risks overlooking important warning signs.
What makes a criminal organisation different?
A criminal organisation is like a parasite. It cannot exist independently and always needs other organisations in order to survive. In effect, criminal organisations borrow parts of the business processes of legitimate organisations. They do not have their own transport department, for example, so they exploit the transport functions of companies that own lorries. They also use the bank accounts of young people (so-called ‘money mules’) to carry out transactions while keeping themselves out of sight. Criminal benefactors may support sports clubs facing financial difficulties, thereby creating opportunities to launder money. Or they may give substantial tips to pub landlords so that criminal networks can use a function room at the back of the pub to meet and discuss their affairs.
Criminal enterprises differ significantly from legitimate businesses. They generally have no formal structure, no transparent accounts and no control mechanisms such as accountants’ checks or audits. They often operate as informal networks in which personal relationships matter more than positions or organisational charts.
Because these networks must constantly take police investigations and criminal prosecution into account, they operate in an environment that they themselves perceive as hostile. This affects their organisational culture.
Trust plays a central role. Not the trust that develops through professional cooperation, but trust based on loyalty. Criminal organisations therefore often consist of family networks, childhood friendships or people who share a common background. Precisely because the risks are so high, key positions are often given to people who have known one another for many years.
Another characteristic is that conflicts are not resolved through the normal legal system. Someone who breaks an agreement, passes information to the police or becomes involved in a failed drug deal cannot simply go to court. Instead, conflicts are settled through displays of power, intimidation or violence.
Secrecy and concealment are also essential. Agreements are recorded as little as possible, responsibilities are obscured and activities are deliberately kept out of sight. The aim is always the same: to prevent illegal activities from being traced back to those responsible, and particularly to those giving the orders.
How organisational culture develops
No organisational culture stands still. Companies constantly adapt to changing circumstances. In doing so, new ideas, habits, norms and ways of working emerge.
Culture essentially develops in two ways. Sometimes an organisation develops new solutions to problems it encounters, together with the beliefs and norms associated with those solutions. For example, suppose a restaurant discovers that a ‘money-maker dish’ has suddenly become less popular with customers. What solution will the chef and the team come up with to compensate for the loss of revenue? Organisations also regularly adopt practices from outside. The rapid uptake of artificial intelligence by translation agencies, IT companies and law firms is an example. It offers a way of reducing staff costs and remaining competitive.
Criminal interference, however, leads to a particular form of adopting solutions from outside. It does not simply introduce new ways of working into a legitimate organisation; it can also bring in ways of thinking, norms and patterns of behaviour associated with a criminal environment.